As populations grow denser and climate patterns bring more intense rainfall, sewer infrastructure can struggle to keep pace with sudden surges in volume. According to estimates by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), approximately 850 billion gallons of untreated wastewater and stormwater are released into U.S. rivers, lakes and coastal areas each year. Just as we wouldn’t tolerate plumbing backups in our own homes, we shouldn’t accept sewage overflows in our cities.
Underground wastewater equalization (EQ) containment tanks are a critical asset in modern municipal and industrial infrastructure because they help prevent excess wastewater from overwhelming our treatment plants and forcing untreated water directly into local rivers and neighborhoods.
As a proven civil engineering design tool, solutions utilizing large subsurface storage tanks can provide several benefits:
Because these tanks store large volumes of chemically aggressive and environmentally hazardous fluids, their design requires attention to several aspects, including structural capacity, corrosion resistance, service life, and straightforward inspection and maintenance. These design parameters also must be balanced with other considerations such as site constraints and project budget to provide a safe, resilient and cost-effective wastewater containment tank.
The following provides a general overview of some of the preliminary design considerations for large-volume wastewater containment tanks to help municipalities and owners develop a successful design strategy, avoid environmental fines and mitigate public health issues.
Wastewater storage volume depends on a variety of factors, including local rainfall intensity, watershed area and population size. For smaller communities, localized CSO/SSO storage may range from 20,000 to 500,000 gallons, whereas a medium to large city may include multiple watershed areas, each requiring 1 million to several million gallons of storage.
Determining the peak-flow storage volume (or equalization volume) requires a comparison of the cumulative volume difference between the incoming wet-weather flow hydrograph and the maximum allowable outflow rate routed to the downstream treatment plant. The tank should have enough volume to contain the maximum expected excess flow surge for a given area and rain event.
For areas with space constraints, high land values or zoning codes, municipal SSO and CSO systems may be installed underground, allowing the surface on top to be used for parking lots, parks or other facilities. Buried structures such as large-diameter pipe arrays or concrete vaults can offer some advantages over above-ground alternatives:
Optimally, the storage system should be located in an area that allows an efficient connection to the existing interceptor trunkline and can utilize gravity flow to minimize the need for an additional lift station.
An “inline” design configuration places the storage system directly in series with the main flow path, and all incoming wastewater flows straight through the storage vessel under normal conditions. This provides for a simple design layout with fewer diversions but allows the entire volume of flow to mix through the tank during heavy surges, which can stir up settled solids.
An “offline” design configuration typically is stationed parallel to the main flow path, and a flow-control device (such as a high-level side weir) is used to prevent effluent from entering the storage tank until the trunkline reaches a set capacity or trigger level. After the rain event has passed, effluent can be routed back to the wastewater treatment plant during off-peak or low-flow hours.
Large-volume subsurface containment tanks are traditionally evaluated as a concrete storage vault or a large-diameter pipe-array system such as steel-reinforced polyethylene (SRPE), high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or fiberglass. These solutions offer the ability to contain a significant amount of wastewater in a relatively localized footprint. A rectangular layout is most common, with depth and dimensions depending on the vertical constraints and site geography. Storage options typically will utilize an equalizer or header at the downstream end to drain the system toward the outlet control structure or pump station.
Structural design to accommodate any dead, live and hydrostatic loads should be evaluated for the chosen material options. A concrete vault will act as a rigid box and require heavy reinforcing steel to resist bending moments in the slabs and walls with the standard structural design following ACI 350. As a heavy structure, controlling differential settlement through a competent subgrade foundation also is important.
Structural loading for a large-diameter pipe array is achieved utilizing traditional pipe-backfill interaction, allowing the pipe to act in ring compression with the backfill around it. Lateral support from the backfill is used to transfer loads, so the quality and placement of backfill is important—a class I crushed angular stone or gravel in accordance with ASTM D2321 is recommended for the massive pipe sizes used in a CSO/SSO pipe array. It’s interesting to note that because SRPE incorporates steel reinforcing ribs within the HDPE pipe wall, the structural design follows AASHTO LRFD Sec.12.7 (steel pipe methodology) rather than unreinforced thermoplastic design. Also, if the design will take any future seismic activity concerns into account, a flexible pipe system generally is preferable to a rigid system due to its resiliency and load-distribution geometry.
As one may imagine, the internal environment of a large sanitary tank can be exceptionally hostile, so resistance to corrosion is important. Microbially induced corrosion (MIC) occurs when anaerobic bacteria in wastewater generate hydrogen sulfide gas (H2S), which converts to sulfuric acid when it meets moisture on the walls above the water line. This acid can damage concrete, so a specialized antimicrobial admixture or internal protective coating should be used. SPRE, HDPE and fiberglass are inherently resistant to MIC and degradation associated with storing sanitary wastewater.
Due to their immense storage volume, underground containment tanks can generate significant buoyant forces if they’re empty and become submerged in groundwater. If the high seasonal groundwater elevation for the selected site is above the invert of the system, then the tank must be checked for flotation. The buoyant uplift force is equal to the area of water displaced multiplied by the unit weight of water (62.4 lb/ft3). The resisting forces include the weight of the tank, the weight of the overburden on top of the tank and any fluid in the tank. A prudent approach is to assume the tank is empty, such as during cleaning. If the resisting forces aren’t enough to overcome the uplift force, then there are options to address this:
Due to immense size, the post-installation testing of large-capacity subsurface wastewater storage systems can be very difficult. The following are a few methods and some considerations:
In addition to the municipal coordination and time of filling the tank with several hundred thousand or millions of gallons of water, the disposal may also have considerations. If the hydrotest water has picked up any chemical residues, concrete particulates or form release agents, it may require an NPDES permit before releasing into surface waters or fees to discharge into a publicly owned treatment facility.
Finally, the exact location of any leaks present may be very difficult to identify with a hydrostatic leak-down test. Some professional industry services offer acoustic leak detection (hydrophones) or fluorescent tracer dye injections using a diver or submersible remote-operated vehicle employed at specific zones of the tank to try and locate problem spots.
Both concrete vaults and large-diameter pipe-array systems utilize integrated access risers to allow physical access inside the tank to perform periodic inspections. Properly trained and equipped personnel following OSHA standards can inspect for sediment buildup and provide condition assessment. The concrete structure should include inspection of the wall joints, roof slab, floor slab and supports for signs of structural cracking, chemical attack, spalling or exposed rebar. The pipe-array inspection should include inspection of the pipe joints, manifold and stub connections.
Any accumulated sludge can be removed using vacuum trucks or high-pressure jetting. The vault allows more open movement, but cleaning the floor surface can be more difficult than the cylindrical barrels of a pipe-array, which promote channel-flow toward the outlet.
Click on the button below to start the quiz for this course. Your score will be tabulated while you wait, and you will receive your certificate upon completion if you correctly answer eight or more questions.
Registration on v1-education.com is required to access the quiz. Use the "Sign Up" link in the top right of v1-education.com to register. If you are already registered simply enter your credentials to access the quiz.
The Professional Development Series is a unique opportunity to earn continuing education credit by reading specially focused, sponsored articles in Informed Infrastructure.
If you read the following article, display your understanding of the stated learning objectives, and follow the simple instructions, you can fulfill a portion of your continuing education requirements at no cost to you. This article also is available online at v1-education.com.
Upon completion of this article, the reader should be able to:
Click on the button below to start the quiz for this course. Your score will be tabulated while you wait, and you will receive your certificate upon completion if you correctly answer eight or more questions.
Registration on v1-education.com is required to access the quiz. Use the "Sign Up" link in the top right of v1-education.com to register. If you are already registered simply enter your credentials to access the quiz.