Pipe stiffness is likely the most commonly referenced and least understood performance parameter in the pipe industry.

When most people think of pipes or try to describe pipes, they first describe it by the material it’s manufactured with (i.e. concrete, HDPE, steel, PVC, etc.).  They may also describe it by some physical attributes such as by it’s joint type (i.e. bell-spigot, welded, flanged) or whether it’s a solid wall (SDR) or profile wall.

However, none of those items would be considered properties that would describe the pipes performance.  Quantitative descriptions of performance properties are harder to identify.  If the pipe is designed for pressurized usage, then the pressure rating would qualify as one of those terms.  However, most pipes don’t have a pressure rating.

That’s likely why pipe stiffness has been latched onto by many engineers as a property that is intended to describe the performance of a pipe.  And pipe stiffness does describe the performance of a pipe – sort of. 

Pipe stiffness measures the load required to deflect an unsupported pipe a distance equal to 5% of its diameter at a specific temperature and at a prescribed rate of loading.  Period.  Pipes with high stiffnesses can resist deformations during the handling and installation of the pipes, but they have little impact on pipe performance once the pipe is installed.

Understanding the pipe stiffness of a pipe is good information to know, but because it’s one of the few quantitative performance measures available, the relevance of the measured stiffness is sometimes overstated.  For instance, some people believe that a pipe with a higher pipe stiffness can carry more load than another pipe with a lower pipe stiffness.  This is not true.  There are plenty of examples of pipes with lower measured pipe stiffnesses that can carry higher cover depths than similar pipes that have a higher pipe stiffness.  Corrugated steel pipes can support fill depths much deeper than plastic pipes, but their pipe stiffnesses are frequently similar to the plastic pipes.

There is also some thought that a pipe with a higher pipe stiffness will perform better over time as compared to a pipe with a lower measured pipe stiffness.  This is technically true, but the degree of difference in performance is so slight that it is essentially negligible in most cases.  Highlighting the limited impact that pipe stiffness has on long term performance of pipelines was the topic of an article I recently wrote for Informed Infrastructure.  In the article, I provide quantitative evidence of the limited impact that pipe stiffness has on long term pipe performance.

Pipe stiffness is a meaningful property for pipes.  A pipe needs to have enough stiffness to resist the transportation, handling and installation of the pipe without deforming excessively.  However, pipe stiffness has little impact when describing the strength of the pipe in carrying soil loads or on the long term performance of the pipe.

Written by:

Author Biography

Darrell Sanders, P.E., is chief engineer for Contech Engineered Solutions. He holds a BS degree in Civil Engineering from the University of Cincinnati and an MBA from the University of Dayton. He holds a Professional Engineering license in several states. Sanders is a member of several industry committees, including NCSPA, AASTHO, ASTM, and CSA. Darrell can be contacted at dsanders@conteches.com.

Post Rating

Comments

Thursday, March 16, 2017 11:49 AM
Pipe stiffness is an important indicator of a pipe's brute strength. That is, how does it perform without a soil envelope? In that sense, stiffness is an indicator of its dependence on the quality of the soil around it. Flexible pipes often rely on the soil to supply as much as 90% of is structural performance. I crawled through miles of ADS' N-12 pipe years ago and saw first-hand how an 'easy-to-install' pipe performed shortly after installation.

That's why our firm designs a high-quality, high stiffness soil envelope around larger-diameter plastic pipes, and we inspect the installations full-time.

I started my career at Armco, and spent 8 years in the concrete pipe industry. Ironically, we do not allow concrete pipe (my decision) for sanitary sewers because we've had too many hydrogen sulfide failures. Toward the end of my tenure in the concrete industry, I developed a presentation tilted "Plastic pipe will work--let me show you how." That presentation form the basis of our current plastic pipe specs.

Post Comment

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above:

Text/HTML