# Siting Considerations for Open-Bottom

Buried Precast Concrete Bridge Structures

By Julia Frazier, P.E.

## Learning Objectives

After reading this article you should understand:

- Application options for open-bottom structures;
- Terminology used to describe a buried bridge structure;
- Items needed to complete a layout of a structure;
- The procedure to align and specify the lengths for wingwalls properly.

*Online quiz for this article is no longer available.*

## Overview

Open-bottom bridges are structures built with side walls and a top that is either flat or in an arc formation. With either configuration, the bottom is not constructed as part of the bridge structure, which provides a foundation design that is separate from the structural design of the bridge. The structure sides support the surrounding soil while the open bottom has the flexibility for a variety of site adaptations. This feature is useful with existing streambed conditions where it is essential to reduce disturbance of the site. Where the bridge spans over the streambed, the natural soils can be preserved, assisting in the sustainability of wildlife and fish passage. A buried bridge structure limits the exposed structural elements, reducing maintenance time and costs by protecting against the exposure to bridge de-icing materials. A prefabricated concrete structure is constructed at an offsite precast plant location and delivered to the site, reducing the overall construction time as compared with onsite conventional stick-built type bridge structures.

Prefabricated, buried bridges can be used in a number of site intersections. These include, but are not limited to, railway over/under roadway, roadway over roadway, airplane passage over roadway, and roadway over streambed. Because the roadway over streambed application is the most common site intersection for buried, three-sided structures, this article describes the conditions related to that type. Many of the site considerations presented in this article can be adapted if a different intersection is under consideration.

## Terminology

Figures 1 and 2 depict some of the basic terminology used to identify the components of a prefabricated buried bridge structure. As opposed to conventional bridges, the overall length of a buried bridge refers to end measurement along the centerline of the span. The span and rise are used to delineate the size of the structure. The span is measured at the inside face of the structure, perpendicular to the bridge legs (the vertical side component of the precast bridge structure).

With open-bottom structures, it is often necessary to differentiate between bridge rise and clear rise. The bridge rise is the dimension from the bottom of the prefabricated structure to the inside structure top measured at the midspan, where the height is the greatest. The clear rise is measured from the underpass or streambed elevation to the underside of the bridge at the midspan. Because the clear rise can vary throughout the length of the bridge, the clear rise is often given at both the upper and lower ends of the structure.

Prefabricated bridges will often be shipped to the site in segments. The length of each bridge segment is called the lay length. The lay lengths may vary based on the weight of each piece, the form lengths, or to meet the required overall bridge length. Transportation limitations such as dimensional size may also require a limitation on the lay lengths. When all of the bridge segments are put together, the overall bridge length can be obtained.

In situations where the streambed and roadway overpass intersection are not perpendicular to each other, a skew angle may be depicted. There are two skew angles that can be specified for the bridge layout. The first is the roadway skew angle, referring to the angle between a line perpendicular to the structure and the centerline of the roadway. The second is the prefabricated unit skew angle. The unit skew is the angle between the fascia of the unit end and the structure. The unit skew and the roadway skew do not need to be, and often are not, at the same angle.

When installing a buried bridge on a slope, the standard construction of the precast units will result with the end face being perpendicular to the foundation slope. In situations where the bridge ends are desired to remain plumb, the bridge end units can be designed with a beveled end face. In this case, the upstream or upper end would be fabricated with a wider lay length at the top of the structure than the bottom. Likewise, the downstream or lower end would be fabricated with the wider lay length at the bottom of the legs than the top. When the pieces are positioned together, the foundation and bridge will be at a slope, but the upper/lower faces would be plumb.

Because the bridge is installed below the ground surface, it is often necessary to retain the soil above and around the bridge with a headwall and wingwalls. A headwall is located at the ends of the bridge to retain the soil on top of the bridge structure. The wingwalls are vertical elements that attach to the bridge ends and act as retaining walls for the soil around the bridge structure, while transitioning the grade from the roadway to the streambed. Proper layout of the wingwalls is subsequently discussed in more detail.

The foundation is an essential element to the structural stability of the bridge. With open-bottom structures, the foundation is placed under the entire length of the bridge structure to support the bridge legs and distribute the load to the soil. There are a variety of foundation options that can be used including strip footing, pedestal footing, deep foundation, or base slab design.

## Siting

Many siting considerations are common to all bridges, while others are more specific to buried and open-bottom structures. All stream-crossing bridges require the proper location and must meet hydraulic requirements. Other common siting considerations include reviewing the natural terrain to find the most efficient placement for the structure, identifying the relationship of the roads and intersecting streambeds, determining the size of the bridge necessary for stream hydraulics, and the soil grade above the structure.

Natural site conditions should be taken into account to determine the optimal location of the bridge. When spanning a waterway, the bridge should match the natural alignment of the streambed in both horizontal angle and vertical grade. The siting should also consider a location that can minimize the overall length of the bridge, which is achieved where the streambed is perpendicular to the road above. However, many times this ideal layout location may not be attainable.

Prior to designing the bridge structure, the following items — discussed later in this article — should be obtained to determine the proper layout of the bridge structure:

- Overall site plan (e.g., roadway and stream alignment, right-of-way information, site features)
- Grading plan
- Soil parameters for backfilling and bearing capacities
- Hydraulic requirements
- Roadway cross sections

- Foundation selection
- Bearing capacity
- Scour protection
- Hydraulics
- Environmental factors

The site plan will identify the roadway and stream alignments, right-of-way information, and other site features in the project area. The grading plan will assist in determining the amount of cover over the structure after the bridge rise has been established.

A geotechnical engineer should perform a geotechnical site investigation. If the geotechnical engineer determines that the soils will likely become unstable with the concentrated water flow beneath the bridge, foundation depths could be lowered to prevent scouring or other scour countermeasures could be implemented. Elevations of any rock formations should be provided and taken into consideration.

The amount of cover — or soil — over the bridge should also be considered when determining the bridge location. As a minimum, the cover should typically be sufficient to maintain the pavement cross-section over the structure to ensure good pavement performance. Also, underground utilities should be considered if they are to be located in the fill over the bridge. With buried bridges, the ability to locate utilities in the backfill over the top of the structure is often advantageous and therefore may have a direct impact on the cover requirements. Contact the manufacturer for the maximum cover limits.

## Summary of siting considerations procedure

- Begin with the horizontal and vertical alignments of roadway and streambed.
- Establish bottom of footing elevation from scour, frost, and soil bearing considerations.
- Determine size of structure based on hydraulic capacity, width and height available at the site, and economics of shape (span, rise, footing thickness, and type).
- Plot roadway berm lines and spot elevatons.
- Plot toe of stream bank and spot elevations.
- Establish cross slopes of roadway embankments and stream bank.
- Determine the overall length of the structure
- Determine top of headwall elevations from height and slope of structure (if needed).
- Determine the lengths and slopes of the wingwalls.

## Determining span and rise

When dealing with structures over waterways, the proper span (width of the opening) and bridge rise (height) will mainly depend on stream hydraulics. For waterway applications, interior bridge dimensions will establish a minimum bridge size to obtain the proper flow-through volume and headwater requirements. However, the principles of hydraulic engineering are outside the scope of this article.

For most waterway applications, the structure must — at a minimum — span the width of the stream channel. The spans over waterways could also be controlled by environmental considerations such as fish passage, maintenance of natural stream morphology, animal migration, and adjacent wetlands, all of which could increase the required span. When dealing with bridges for roadway and railway applications, it also is necessary to take into account proper clearances, including vehicular heights and widths, to determine the minimum size span and rise dimensions for the structure. The rise dimension also has to take the elevations from the underpass/overpass differences into account.

## Slope

The bridge can be installed with or without a slope along the length of the bridge. The degree of slope is based on the upper and lower end elevations. For hydraulic reasons, it is often desired to have a constant flow-through area throughout the length of the bridge. If there is a considerable difference in grade between the upstream and downstream ends, a slope may be required to provide this constant opening size. However, because the bridge system is open-bottom, it is also permissible to install the bridge flat and establish the slope in the streambed to match existing grades. This application is optimal where the upper and lower end elevations can provide adequate flow-through open area at both upstream and downstream clear rises.

## Length

The length of the bridge will primarily be determined by the road's cross-section, including berm and sidewalks (if applicable). Determining the length of the bridge should begin by adding up the following items (see Figure 3):

- Roadway cross-sectional width
- Required berm/shoulder width
- Headwall width

After a minimum length has been determined, any additional bridge length requirements should be considered. The height difference between the top of the bridge structure and the roadway width can be retained by a headwall or the length of the bridge can be extended so that the ground is naturally graded to match the bridge top, or a combination of the two. Note that it is often more economical to extend the bridge length and slope the fill behind the headwall to create a shorter headwall and wingwalls than to shorten the bridge length. Therefore, the horizontal dimension of the desired slope — transitional grade — should be added to the bridge length. Also, if the roadway overpass is at a skew to the underpass, the bridge length may need to be extended to provide the adequate clear distance for the roadway width.

Working within designated right-of-ways may restrict the construction area; therefore, it is important to identify these dimensions and constraints when laying out the bridge. Other site features often shown on the site plan that may affect the bridge location or alignment include utilities, existing buildings, and environmental considerations.

## Headwalls

The minimal headwall height will be the depth of soil behind the headwall. The height should be increased if the guiderail application requires it or if there are some sitespecific aesthetic conditions desired.

Four main factors affect the headwall height:

- Depth of soil it is retaining
- Guiderail system (where applicable)
- Aesthetic considerations
- Constructability

The thickness of the headwall is determined by the structural design. The headwall needs to be designed to retain the soil behind the wall and to resist vehicular impact loading, when applicable. If the guiderail is required to be attached directly to the headwall, the minimum thickness of the headwall may be determined by the configuration of the anchor bolts of the guiderail attachment. However, if there is sufficient earth fill, it is often more economical to bury the guiderail in the fill in front of the precast headwall.

## Wingwalls

The wingwall layout will require considerations for both height and alignment. The wingwalls retain the soil behind the wall for a distance until the soil is capable of sloping without a separation of grades between the roadway and streambed slopes.

The wingwall splay — or alignment — is the angle of the wingwall in reference to the centerline of the bridge. The angle is determined by the roadway embankment slope and bank slopes. The optimum wingwall alignment is primarily based on the proposed grading of the roadway embankment and streambed bank slopes, while also taking into consideration any site-related constraints that may limit the desired layout (see Figure 4).

Given equal slopes from the road and the stream, the most efficient wingwall angle is to split the angle between the centerline of the bridge and the centerline of the roadway angles. This allows the grade alongside the road to slope down while providing an area for the stream channel to rise. In estimating wingwall parameters, a reasonable soil slope should be assumed based on the soil type, which is often found in the geotechnical report for the project site.

## Siting Considerations for Open-Bottom Buried Precast Concrete Bridge Structures

Equation 1 can be used to calculate the splay for any grade combination (for a nonskewed application):

**Equation 1: **

**T = tan-1(Roadway slope/bank slope)**

The primary factor for determining the wingwall length is the desired grading around the wall. The elevation difference between the underpass and overpass elevations at the headwall is used as the total height difference (H).

The length of the wingwall (L ) can be calculated with Equation 2:

**Equation 2:**

**L = H/[(sin a)/Roadway slope) + (sin T)/streambank slope)]**

where:

**a** = 90 degrees – T.

The elevation at the end of the wingwall is based on the elevation of where the roadway slope and streambank slope intersect. If the grading of the underpass and the overpass were at the same slope, then the wingwall drop would be half of the full retaining height; however, when the grades are different, Equation 3 can be followed:

**Equation 3:**

**Drop = Wingwall length [(sin a)/roadway slope)] **

For example: A non-skewed bridge has a grade elevation at the headwall that is 10 feet higher than the elevation at the streambed. The roadway embankment will be sloped at 5H:1V and the streambed bank will slope at 2H:1V. What is the most efficient wingwall alignment? (Assume the streambed has a constant elevation throughout the bridge span.)

Using **Equation 1**, the splay would be equal to:

* T = tan-1(5/2) = 68 degrees for the angle with the stream*

If the stream and roadway are perpendicular to each other, then the angle with the roadway is 90 degrees - 68 degrees = 22 degrees.

Using**Equation 2**, the wingwall length equals:

* L = 10 feet/[(sin(22 degrees)/5) + (sin(68 degrees)/2)] = 18.6 feet*

**Equation 3**, the wingwall drop equals:

*Drop = 18.6 feet [(sin(22 degrees))/5] = 1.4 feet*

## Conclusion

Proper siting and layout of prefabricated buried open bottom bridge structures requires a number of project considerations. Even though some of the considerations are common with other types of bridge structures, the buried structure does have some that are specific to it. Many of these decisions will impact the cost of the bridge, ease of construction, and overall performance of the structure. By understanding the existing and proposed applications, the choices made at the beginning of the project can work to achieve a sustainable application for the future.

**Julia Frazier, P.E.**, is a senior structural engineer for CONTECH Construction Products Inc. and specializes in precast bridge products.